RIGHTS, RULES, AND DEMOCRACY

  • Richard S. Kay, University of Connecticut-School of Law, Estados Unidos University of Connecticut School of Law

Resumo

Abstract: Democracy require protection of certain fundamental rights, but can we expect courts to follow rules? There seems little escape from the proposition that substantive constitutional review by an unelected judiciary is a presumptive abridgement of democratic decision-making. Once we have accepted the proposition that there exist human rights that ought to be protected, this should hardly surprise us. No one thinks courts are perfect translators of the rules invoked before them on every occasion. But it is equally clear that rules sometimes do decide cases. In modern legal systems the relative roles of courts and legislators with respect to the rules of the system is a commonplace. Legislatures make rules. Courts apply them in particular disputes. When we are talking about human rights, however, that assumption must be clarified in at least one way. The defense of the practice of constitutional review in this article assumes courts can and do enforce rules. This article also makes clear what is the meaning of “following rules”. Preference for judicial over legislative interpretation of rights, therefore, seems to hang on the question of whether or not judges are capable of subordinating their own judgment to that incorporated in the rules by their makers. This article maintains that, in general, entrenched constitutional rules (and not just constitutional courts) can and do constrain public conduct and protect human rights. The article concludes that the value judgments will depend on our estimate of the benefits we derive from the process of representative self-government. Against those benefits we will have to measure the importance we place on being able to live our lives with the security created by a regime of human rights protected by the rule of law.

Keywords: Democracy. Human Rights. Rules. Judicial Review.

Downloads

Não há dados estatísticos.

Biografia do Autor

Richard S. Kay, University of Connecticut-School of Law, Estados Unidos, University of Connecticut School of Law
Faculty of the University of Connecticut School of Law since 1974 and is currently the Wallace Stevens Professor of Law. Master of Arts degree in Economics from Yale University. He was graduated magna cum laude from Harvard Law School where he was an editor of the Harvard Law Review. After law school he was a clerk on the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts. He teaches basic and advanced courses in constitutional law, comparative law and commercial law. He is treasurer of the American Comparative Law Society and an elected member of the International Academy of Comparative Law. He is a past chair of the Constitutional Law Section of the Association of American Law Schools.
Publicado
09-11-2012
Como Citar
Kay, University of Connecticut-School of Law, Estados Unidos, R. (2012). RIGHTS, RULES, AND DEMOCRACY. Espaço Jurídico Journal of Law [EJJL], 151-167. Recuperado de https://portalperiodicos.unoesc.edu.br/espacojuridico/article/view/2011